Italy bans couples from going abroad for surrogacy
As in most European countries, surrogacy is illegal in Italy. The Italian parliament has now passed a law that also criminalises the use of such services abroad. The right-wing populist government coalition justifies the ban saying that the traditional family model needs to be protected. For the national press, this ignores the real issue.
Drastic language, drastic penalties
La Repubblica emphasises:
“'Universal crime'. These two words were repeated several times in the Senate chamber yesterday and were celebrated as a victory by the parliamentary majority. ... The bill makes surrogacy, which has already been banned in Italy for 20 years, a punishable offence even if the couple does it in another country where it is permitted. The parents can be charged as soon as they return to Italy, go to prison for three months to two years and have to pay a fine of between 600,000 and one million euros. A very harsh law.”
Fight fertility tourism - but not like this
La Stampa calls for stricter rules on surrogate motherhood:
“There is a need, and a very urgent one at that, for discussion and education on this issue. ... What is needed is responsibility, humanity and courage, not ideological posturing, let alone rhetoric. ... Surrogacy is a global phenomenon that relies on transnational networks based in the countries where it is allowed - of which there are not many, and most of which are located in the poorest regions of the world. These agencies offer legal assistance, insurance guarantees, doctors and logistics in exchange for a fee. They press for controls to be relaxed and for reproductive tourism to take place without hindrance. This is the level at which action is needed.”